Home Services Why Bowthorpe Photos Contact Us Links Français
Contact Us
Tree Removal & Pruning
Why Not To Top
Value Of Trees
Choosing A Tree
 
 

Why You Should Never Top A Tree



  • Your tree is valuable asset to your property, topping it will result in an unsightly, disfigured tree.

  • Topping is not a quick fix. You will end up paying more for tree care because numerous watersprouts (upright vigorous stems) will grow back faster and denser than before. See diagram below:

A deciduous tree just

been topped

After 1 year, the tree

reaches its original height

After 3 years, the tree

is denser than before



  • Watersprouts are weakly attached to the trunk and can pose a danger.

  • A mature tree may not recover from being topped. If you remove most of the foliage then the tree will not be able to produce enough food to sustain itself.

  • A tree does not heal well from a topping cut and will be more prone to diseases and pests.

  • If your tree has a light bark such as beech or a birch, the bark can become sunburned.


Here are two really good examples of terrible tree care.

 

The example on the left is a picture I found online.

 

The picture on the right is a tree here in Ottawa, on Woodroffe Ave that I noted being pruned incorrectly last year (2008).

This is akin to topping as all the ends have been hacked off.


If your tree has outgrown it's location, the safest option is to remove it, rather than top it. If you are planning to plant a tree, take the potential size of the tree into consideration when choosing a species. See Choosing a tree for some guidelines or have one of our experienced professionals guide you.